Green Beret micro poll: what do you think about it's quality? (General discussion Foros MSX)MSX Resource Center            
                       
English Nederlands Espa�ol Portugu�s Russian                  
 Noticias
   Página principal
  Almacén de noticias
  Temas de noticias

 Recursos
   Foros MSX
  Artículos
  Analisis
  Informe de ferias/RUs
  Álbum de fotos
  Ferias y encuentros
  Encuestas
  Enlaces
  Buscar

 Software
   Descargas
  Tienda Online

 MRC
   Quiénes somos
  Únete a nuestro equipo
  Donar
  Políticas
  Contacta con nosotros
  Enlázanos
  Estadísticas

 Buscar
 
  

  

 Login
 

Login

Contraseña




¿Aún no tienes una cuenta? ¡Conviértete en miembro del MSX Resource Center! ¡Únete a nosotros!.


 Estadísticas
 

Hay 42 invitados y 2 miembros en línea

Eres un usuario anónimo.
 

Foros MSX


Foros MSX

General discussion - Green Beret micro poll: what do you think about it's quality?

Ir a la página ( Página anterior 1 | 2 | 3 Siguiente página )
Autor

Green Beret micro poll: what do you think about it's quality?

PingPong
msx master
Mensajes: 1069
Publicado: Marzo 09 2007, 16:06   
@jltursan: could they design a arcade like gfx sprites with msx1 sprites? i think no. So the reason for the new set of sprites.
@huey: non new project, only a matter of curiosity. My opinion is (green beret): this is the max we can get on msx1 .
I was only wondering if anyone could do better.
SLotman
msx professional
Mensajes: 561
Publicado: Marzo 09 2007, 16:50   
Before anything else... *** the image below is just a test ***



The background could be much more detailed, and if the enemies somehow could be made as shapes (not sprites), the player could be just like in the picture...

But I agree this game screams MSX2
(as Jailbreak screams MSX2+ with it's sidescrolling... thanks God noone ported the Spectrum version, which is soooooo bad it's almost disgusting)
PingPong
msx master
Mensajes: 1069
Publicado: Marzo 09 2007, 16:52   
Quote:

Before anything else... *** the image below is just a test ***



The background could be much more detailed, and if the enemies somehow could be made as shapes (not sprites), the player could be just like in the picture...

But I agree this game screams MSX2
(as Jailbreak screams MSX2+ with it's sidescrolling... thanks God noone ported the Spectrum version, which is soooooo bad it's almost disgusting)


What screen is? a msx 2 screen i suppose...
SLotman
msx professional
Mensajes: 561
Publicado: Marzo 09 2007, 17:03   
Yup, screen 2. Dont know which screen the game uses, but as I said, this was a quick hack job just to see what it could be...

For me the game is an Ok job, but nothing near Konami-quality... So, yes, I think with talented gfx artists, the game could at least look a little better...
PingPong
msx master
Mensajes: 1069
Publicado: Marzo 09 2007, 17:36   
Quote:

Yup, screen 2. Dont know which screen the game uses, but as I said, this was a quick hack job just to see what it could be...

For me the game is an Ok job, but nothing near Konami-quality... So, yes, I think with talented gfx artists, the game could at least look a little better...


If at old days msx user could have this gfx quality, i think they were more satisfied...


PingPong
msx master
Mensajes: 1069
Publicado: Marzo 09 2007, 18:17   
SlotMan:Just to see, can you make a screen shot of the very first part of the game? thx


manuel
msx guru
Mensajes: 3635
Publicado: Marzo 09 2007, 22:46   
IMHO, there is hardly any annoying flickering or transparency of sprites in MoG. This game just rocks in all senses.
SLotman
msx professional
Mensajes: 561
Publicado: Marzo 10 2007, 13:50   
Another quick test, the initial screen:



Needs a lot of work on the upper bridge part, but the lower part is a lot better than the original....
PingPong
msx master
Mensajes: 1069
Publicado: Marzo 10 2007, 14:18   
Thx slotman, look really GOOD!
Ivan

msx professional
Mensajes: 935
Publicado: Marzo 10 2007, 17:00   
Green Beret for MSX1... it could have been much better...

Something like Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles (tape for MSX only sold in Spain). Not a bad game at all (although being a ZX Spectrum clone). The NES version is the same game but much better:

TMNT for NES (YouTube)

I wonder why Konami Japan did not launch these two games for MSX, especially TMNT.
Ivan

msx professional
Mensajes: 935
Publicado: Marzo 11 2007, 19:17   
Just played and finished TMHT for MSX1. What an easy game
DemonSeed
msx master
Mensajes: 1062
Publicado: Junio 03 2007, 02:49   
@Ivan, isn't the MSX-version of TMNT just a stripped-down, slowish version of the NES game?
Which two Konami games do you mean?

By the way, through the wonder called MAME I recently played a Konami arcade game called "Mr. Goemon".
The MSX version is unsimilar but better.

Talking about MSX-versions which *could* have been a lot better (looking at those Green Beret shots... Wow, if the original MSX game only could have looked like that and also played more like the arcade version... Where were you guys back then? Heheh. )

But, speaking of it, what about R-Type?

Don't wanna be dissin' the old "1" but in my IMHO this game really deserved an MSX-2 port.
Good thing it supported Fm-Pac though...
Ivan

msx professional
Mensajes: 935
Publicado: Junio 03 2007, 11:58   
Quote:

@Ivan, isn't the MSX-version of TMNT just a stripped-down, slowish version of the NES game?
Which two Konami games do you mean?



Yes, TMNT is the same game for the NES, PC, Amiga, Atari ST, Amstrad CPC, C64, ZX Spectrum and MSX.
Hopefully the ZX Spectrum version -form which the MSX version was ported- was quite good because it wasn't monochrome -as it was usual in ZX Spectrum games- and the colour palette was used efficiently. The NES version came later and it is probably the best (I haven't seen the 16bit versions but I doubt that they can be better than TMNT for the NES).

I was referring to TMNT and Green Beret, specially to TMNT. Konami Japan should have released TMNT on cartridge for MSX2. But when the ZX port appeared in Spain (December 1990-January 1991) Konami had already left the MSX business.

And about R-Type it is an entertaining game but far away from the Nemesis series in all aspects.
Latok
msx master
Mensajes: 1735
Publicado: Junio 03 2007, 12:02   
I liked playing Green Beret on MSX actually
Ivan

msx professional
Mensajes: 935
Publicado: Junio 03 2007, 12:15   
Quote:

The NES version came later and it is probably the best

Well... I've checked TMNT for the NES and the intro screen says 1989. I have also taken a look at an old Spanish magazine and the NES version was already on sale when the versions for 8bit/16bit computers appeared. So the home computer versions are based on the NES game.
 
Ir a la página ( Página anterior 1 | 2 | 3 Siguiente página )
 







(c) 1994 - 2009 Fundación MSX Resource Center. MSX es una marca registrada de MSX Licensing Corporation