Accueil » News » Challenges » MSXdev'11 - Results
MSXdev'11 - Results

MSXdev'11 - Results

par wolf_ on 02-03-2012, 22:41
Sujet: Challenges
Étiquettes: Zombie Incident, MSXdev
Langues:

A month ago, nine MSX games entered the MSXdev'11 arena to battle for the title. After a month of playing, testing and judging, the results are in.

  1. Zombie Incident (Nenefranz)
  2. Alter Ego (TNI)
  3. M-Tanks (Assembler)
  4. Jumping (Dimension Z)
  5. Mecha Eight (Óscar Toledo Gutiérrez)
  6. ExChess (Garlic Soft)
  7. KillMice (Andrea Gasparrini)
  8. Robots (Michel d’Alger)
  9. ZoneTNT (Andrea Gasparrini)

Especially among the top 3, the final scores sit closely together, a testament to this year's quality. Zombie Incident got a score of 86.67% and was the most original game with the best graphics and best music. Alter Ego won a score of 82% and was the most polished game featuring the best gameplay. Assembler, a new member of the MSX scene, won the third place with M-Tanks which scored 75.33%.

With that, MSXdev'11 turns out to be one of the better editions when we look at the quality of the games, it bodes well for the future! For now, Nenefranz, Sun, and our own John Hassink deserve a cheer and a beer for Zombie Incident!

Relevant link: MSXdev'11 - Results

Commentaires (18)

Par mars2000you

Enlighted (6433)

Portrait de mars2000you

02-03-2012, 22:51

Thanks for the news ! Wink

Some corrections :
- score for Zombie Incident is 86,67 %
- the 3 last ones are : 7 - Kill Mice - 8 - Robots - 9 - Zone TNT.

Par wolf_

Ambassador_ (10095)

Portrait de wolf_

02-03-2012, 22:55

Fixed, must have been typing too quick.. oO

Par ro

Scribe (4916)

Portrait de ro

03-03-2012, 11:39

I couldn't find the like button, so I just say "cool" and congrats all. BA-team

Par hap

Paragon (2042)

Portrait de hap

03-03-2012, 12:47

Nice results! Smile
mars if it's possible, I'd like to change my prize rule "Games that ranked 2 to 4 *and* have an overall score of 70% or more will each get 25 €."
to: "Games that ranked 2 to 4 *and* have an overall score of 67.67% or more will each get 25 €."
Is that OK with you? This would mean Jumping gets 25 euros from me.

Par mars2000you

Enlighted (6433)

Portrait de mars2000you

03-03-2012, 12:52

hap : it's OK for me, I'll update the website. Wink

Par mars2000you

Enlighted (6433)

Portrait de mars2000you

03-03-2012, 13:14

hap: just finished the update for your special prize ! Smile

Par hap

Paragon (2042)

Portrait de hap

03-03-2012, 13:22

hooray for spanish jump =p

Par benedick

Resident (36)

Portrait de benedick

03-03-2012, 20:50

Congratulations to the winner! All the entries are high quality; I still find my self playing Mecha Eight!

Par Imanok

Paragon (1199)

Portrait de Imanok

04-03-2012, 00:14

Congrats to the winners! Wink

Except for two swapped positions, the final ranking has been just as I expected it to be Smile

Par nenefranz

Resident (43)

Portrait de nenefranz

04-03-2012, 12:55

THANKSS!! ... and congratulations to all participants in the dev. I think that the most important success of the competition is to obtain nine games for the standard.
I wanted to congratulate and thank John Hassink and Sun (paco) for their great work and help, without them Zombie Incident would not have been what it is.
I would also like to thank to Toni Galvez, Valkyr and Saccophraynx for their advice and help ... any help is apprecitated. Smile
I hope people are encouraged to participate in future editions of the dev. With initiatives like JumpinG (thanks to Pepe Vila), there are few excuses for not daring. Big smile

Best regards,

PS: thanks to NANA for your patience  Wink

Par Huey

Prophet (2694)

Portrait de Huey

04-03-2012, 15:07

Congrats to all.

Par nanochess

Master (222)

Portrait de nanochess

04-03-2012, 20:22

Some weird scores and comments in results oO , but anyway congratulations to winners Smile
@hap: you almost got right your predictions for top three Wink

Par Oscar

Guardian (584)

Portrait de Oscar

05-03-2012, 23:07

Congratulations to everybody. I think Mecha 8 deserves a better position in my opinion. Anyway, a lot of great games!

Par tcruise

Master (133)

Portrait de tcruise

07-03-2012, 08:14

Congrats to the winners, there were some really good games produced by all the contestants.  Some quite impressive techniques used to get the most out of our favourite retro computer system.

Par Wolverine_nl

Paragon (1160)

Portrait de Wolverine_nl

07-03-2012, 12:25

Congrats every1!

Par wolf_

Ambassador_ (10095)

Portrait de wolf_

08-03-2012, 23:19

The first two were as I'd expected. I expected it would eventually be between ZI and AE. It's perhaps the originality that gave ZI the edge.

Par Imanok

Paragon (1199)

Portrait de Imanok

09-03-2012, 19:43

Indeed, the "originality" and "polish" are two determining categories in the final ranking and I think they are not quite well defined/judged.
 
First of all, what is considered original??... a game with a new concept in general?? only within the MSX universe??... whatever the definition may be, I think a game should get some extra points when it's original instead of being penalized when it isn't.
 
About the "polish" thing... IMHO, I consider a game being polished when it has no bugs, when it works perfectly in all machines and configurations, when it checks if the player keeps a key pressed at menus so that the he/she doesn't select the next sub-option by mistake... you know, that kind of things. Extra stuff like demo modes, hidden/unlockable features, etc, fit much more in the the same category than using extra soundchips for the music or taking profit from the MSX2/MSX2+ vdp's capabilities for improvements, not in the "polish" category.

Par mars2000you

Enlighted (6433)

Portrait de mars2000you

10-03-2012, 16:53

MSXdev' : The End

http://msxdev.msxblue.com/?p=1521